Pull Apart
Something
Wonderful
Hand-shaped, traditionally baked, and still warm when you hold it. Come taste the pretzel that's been bringing neighbors together right here on Gibbons Road.
A Small Bakery with a Big Heart
Sara Faye's Soft Pretzels started as a simple idea: bake pretzels the way they used to be made — soft on the inside, perfectly golden on the outside, and sprinkled with just the right amount of coarse salt.
Today, we're proud to serve Upper Leacock Township and the surrounding Lancaster County community from our kitchen on Gibbons Road. Every pretzel is hand-shaped, boiled in the traditional way, and baked fresh throughout the day so you get that warm, just-out-of-the-oven taste in every bite.
Our Pretzel Selection
From the classic salted twist to cheese-dipped favorites, every pretzel is crafted the same way — with patience, tradition, and a whole lot of dough.
Classic Salted Pretzel
The one that started it all. Perfectly chewy with a golden crust and a sprinkle of coarse salt on top.
Pretzel with Cheese Dip
Our warm pretzel paired with a side of creamy, tangy beer cheese dip. An absolute must-try combo.
Cinnamon Sugar Pretzel
A sweeter twist — coated in cinnamon sugar and perfect for when you're craving something deliciously indulgent.
Pretzel Knots
Bite-sized pretzel knots, perfect for snacking on the go. Available salted or cinnamon sugar.
Pretzel Rods
Long, crispy-on-the-outside soft pretzel rods — great for dipping and sharing (if you can resist eating them all).
Seasonal Specials
Keep an eye out for our rotating seasonal flavors — from pumpkin spice to holiday-themed treats that come out a few times a year.
Have a question about ingredients or allergens? We're happy to help.
Call us at (717) 354-3459Why Neighbors Keep Coming Back
There are plenty of places to grab a pretzel. But here's what makes Sara Faye's the one people drive for.
Traditional Recipe
We follow the old ways — hand-shaping, lye bath, and a bake that gives you that authentic pretzel crust every time.
Baked Fresh Daily
We don't freeze and reheat. Every pretzel is made from scratch and baked fresh throughout the day, so it's warm when you buy it.
Community First
We're your neighbors. This is a small-town bakery with a big heart, and we treat every customer like someone we know.
Convenient Location
Right here on Gibbons Road in Upper Leacock — easy to find, easy to stop by on your way home or for a special treat.
What Our Customers Say
"These are hands-down the best pretzels I've had in the area. The cheese dip is incredible, and they're always warm. We stop here every time we're in the neighborhood."
M.R.
Upper Leacock Township
"Brought my kids here and they were amazed — you can watch them make the pretzels right in the window. It's become our weekend tradition. The cinnamon sugar ones are a hit every time."
J.T.
Lancaster County
"I drove past here on a whim and I'm so glad I stopped. The pretzels are so fresh and soft — nothing like the frozen stuff you get at the store. This is the real deal. Will definitely be back!"
S.L.
Nearby Visitor
Come Say Hello
We'd love to see you! Stop by our bakery for a warm pretzel, or give us a call if you have questions or want to place an order.
Our Location
542 Gibbons Rd
Upper Leacock Township, PA 17505
Hours
Monday – Saturday
7:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Closed Sundays
Looking for us?
We're located on Gibbons Road in Upper Leacock Township, just off Route 72. Free parking is available right out front.
Fresh Pretzels Are Waiting for You
Stop by 542 Gibbons Rd or give us a call — we're always happy to make your day a little sweeter.
